Peloton Vs. Schwinn Exercise Bike – Who Does It Better?

If you are in the market for a new exercise bike, two of the biggest players in the game are Peloton and Schwinn. Spin bikes have become highly sought after, as more and more people are hopping on the spinning bandwagon after trying a class and realizing how fantastic the workout it is. While Schwinn and Peloton aren’t apples-to-apples competitors, we thought we would look at the two ends of the price spectrum in the category with the intent of giving you a better gauge of what to expect if you’re on a budget versus what features come with a more premium offering. Schwinn’s more recent IC4 comes a bit closer in spec at a basic level than the prior IC3 that we once compared, but these bikes are still a good ways apart once you get away from basic mechanicals and construction.

Peloton has become acutely aware that market competition has increased dramatically since the launch of its at-home bike in 2013, and has recently announced some changes to its lineup to make themselves more competitive again. The original Peloton Bike remains on sale, now coming in at a more affordable sticker price of $1,445 compared to its original $2,245 list price. In addition, the brand has since brought out the Peloton Bike+ with a number of improved features as an updated version of the bike priced at $2,495. This puts the new bike back into the most expensive position in the competitive pool, but it still has an upper hand due to its huge cult following in the indoor cycling world.

So how do Peloton and Schwinn’s IC4 indoor cycle compare? Let’s start with the build specifications.

  Peloton Schwinn
Footprint 48′ long by 24′ wide 48.7″ long by 21.2″ wide
Weight 135 lbs. 106 lbs.
Frame Welded Steel Welded Steel
Resistance Magnetic flywheel resistance system Magnetic flywheel resistance system
Drive Belt Belt
Console Features 21.5 Full HD Touchscreen

(23.8″ for Bike+)

WiFi Connection

LCD Multifunction Display

Heartrate Monitoring

Multimedia Device Holder

Check Price

Check Price

 

Now that you have the basics, here is a closer look at what these differences (and similarities) mean for your actual riding/training experience.

 

peloton

Footprint

To put it simply, the footprint is how much space your bike will take up in a room, and for the most part this shape and style of indoor cycling bike is pretty consistent from brand to brand. The Schwinn model should occupy a little less space than the Peloton though, as it’s about 2.8″ wider and heavier.

Weight

With a 29-pound gap between the Schwinn IC4 and the Peloton, you’re probably thinking this is pretty trivial, right? Not so. Frame/bike weight plays a substantial role in riding stability—as you pedal away harder and harder, the bike is going to want to move with your motions, and the heavier the bike, the more inherently stable it will be. If you weigh less than somewhere around 200 pounds, you won’t really notice a difference, but if you’re presently a little heavier you might find the added heft and rigidity an asset. That said, if you’re going to be moving your bike to a different location when you use it, the Schwinn will be slightly easier to maneuver.

Frame

The frame on both of these bikes is made of high-strength steel, so as far as that goes, you shouldn’t have any issues. Both should hold up just fine and allow you to get a great workout in for years to come. The Schwinn IC4 does offer a superior maximum user weight capacity of 330 pounds relative to the Peloton’s 297 pounds.

Resistance

In its earlier guise (the discontinued IC3) the biggest stumbling block that Schwinn had was the fact that it was running friction resistance instead of magnetic. At present, that game has changed, as the brand was able to deliver a magnetic resistance system in a more affordable and entry-level indoor cycle. The Schwinn also runs a heavier flywheel than its competitor, which in turn creates an extra smooth ride and higher range of max resistance.

Drive

Back to being inherently similar, both of these bikes use a belt drive system connecting the pedals to the flywheel, creating a smooth ride all while limiting noise (compared to the chain drive found on actual bicycles).

Console Features

What really sets these two bikes apart is the console. With the Schwinn, you get the fairly typical LCD console that comes with the normal outputs including heart rate, distance, time, calories, RPM’s, and so forth. In terms of programming, Schwinn is now offering a free one-year membership to the JRNY Fitness App with purchase, and this app is compatible with both phones, tablets, and other smart devices. This bike is also designed to integrate many more programs than its Peloton rival, including MyFitness.Pal, Rouvy, and Sufferfest.

With the Peloton bike however, you get full workouts streamed right in front of you. This bike comes with full WiFi connectivity, so you are able to take part in live spin classes 24/7 that are recorded and broadcast from Peloton studios in New York. This is precisely the selling feature that has garnered Peloton significant attention in the market, and the brand has developed quite the cult following on account of it. This said, there is a fee for this service, so not only does the Peloton cost more to get into your home, but it also commits you to a $39/month membership fee to use it to its full potential. Some people are greatly put off by this, so it could cause them to lean away from this bike entirely. Peloton has a whopping 10 categories of workout classes from which to choose, and a more immersive experience by way of its connectivity. The Peloton Bike+ features a 2.2 channel front-facing stereo soundbar with four speakers.

The other big difference that comes with the new Peloton Bike+ is the increased focus on a total body workout. The Bike+ now has a swiveling screen, and the brand has been ramping up its training offerings for cross training, strength training, yoga, and stretching, as well as adding new Boot Camp programming to the catalog. The volume of instructor-led versatility is impressive, the quality of content is high, and quite frankly it’s worth the extra spend if you’re looking for thorough at-home training through streaming video.

Warranty

When investing money in exercise equipment with streaming capabilities, warranties and guarantees are an important consideration. Here the Schwinn model offers a 10-year warranty on the frame, with three years for parts, and one for labor. Peloton on the other hand offers a 5-year warranty on the frame, one year for parts and labor. Both bikes come from reputable manufacturers and there’s good reason for their customers’ loyalty, that said, we do respect the confidence represented by warranties. The advantage here is clearly with the Schwinn model’s offer.

Conclusion

The million dollar question here is really a matter of what kind of rider you are. Are you a seasoned road cyclist who’s self-motivated and wants to train in the off season? Are you a competitive individual that for whom competition is a huge motivator? Have you spent endless hours in indoor cycling classes like SoulCycle, Spin, and others, and are chasing that experience in a home bike? There are two different schools of thought behind these two bikes, and the answers to the above questions will make all the difference.

Who is the Peloton Rider?

First and foremost, those seeking the indoor cycling class feel from the comfort of their own home will be best suited going the Peloton route, whether the classic Bike or upgraded Bike+. Their instructors remain some of the best in the business, and their wide range of class offerings will satisfy your riding style and competitive spirit no matter if you’re a veteran or an eager but recent convert. This bike is designed solely for following along with instruction, so self-led rides facing a black screen are a bit of a downer, and that also means that you’re committed to the brand’s $39/month subscription for as long as you decide to keep using the bike.

As an added perk, the Bike+ (as we noted above) brings total-body workouts into the mix, which is a nice benefit for those looking for more than just indoor cycling classes. Yoga, stretching, strength training, cross training, and even new Boot Camp programming is a part of the offering, and users are able to swivel the screen to either side of the bike for a clear view while working out (a feature not found on the original Peloton Bike).

Who is the Schwinn IC4 Rider

The answer to this is a touch more open-ended, because the IC4 can satisfy quite a few needs on a budget. The self-motivated on-road cyclists will be plenty satisfied here, as the bike is very well constructed and stable. Simply clip in with your SPD-clip shoes, and you’re off to the races. With the IC4 you can also grab your tablet or iPad, and link up to apps like Zwift, and even the Peloton app for a similar experience to the Peloton on a smaller screen. It’s worth noting that with the Peloton app, metrics are more limited, and you are unable to participate in leaderboard competition (Zwift, on the other hand, has more comprehensive functionality including the leaderboards).

To put it simply, if you aren’t a tech junkie or a spin class fanatic, the Schwinn IC4 will deliver a solid enough experience that you won’t necessarily get much value by spending the additional cash on the Peloton Bike or Bike+.

 

As you can see, there’s a lot to consider when looking at which exercise bike is right for you, but hopefully this handy guide helps clear the air in regards to what value you get at either end of the exercise bike pricing spectrum.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Peloton and Schwinn resistance levels the same?

While both bikes offer 100 levels of resistance, those levels are not equivalent one to the other as the machines are engineered differently.

How much does a Schwinn IC4 cost?

The bike is priced online at $999 with free shipping and a one-year subscription to the JRNY Fitness App included.

Why is Peloton so popular?

In addition to being an outstanding bike, the Peloton exercise app offers a dynamic fitness community with considerable appeal. Once people get into the programming and make new friends around the world, they don't want to quit.

Is Peloton worth the extra money?

We feel the bike is certainly high-quality but a growing number of competitors are certainly giving them a run for their money price-wise. What's interesting is the number of new bikes coming out which allow one to use the Peloton app as well as their own.

Is the Schwinn IC4 compatible with the Peloton App?

Yes, the Schwinn IC4 works with a number of apps, including the Bowflex JRNY system as well as Peloton and Zwift.

2 Comments
  1. Danielle Morris March 29, 2019 at 6:49 am
    Hello, The display console on my Schwinn Carbon Blue exercise bike keeps needing to be replaced. This is very frustrating. Is this technology failing for other people? We have to keep replacing the batteries. The screen keeps failing, or the screen won’t turn on or off, or the screen gets all scrambled. The company has replaced the console twice already. The bike itself works fine. TIA.
    • Bike Reviews Pros March 29, 2019 at 1:08 pm
      Hi Danielle, we are sorry to hear that you have had to replace the screen twice already on your machine. Have you been able to tell Schwinn about this ongoing issue? Were they able to offer an alternative solution to having to replace the console constantly?

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.